Christmas Sugar Cookies
There’s just something about a tray of warm christmas sugar cookies cooling on the counter that instantly turns any day into a full blown holiday moment. These are the kind of holiday cookies for christmas that fill your whole kitchen with buttery sweetness, make you want to put on a cheesy holiday playlist, and get everyone wandering in saying what smells so good. This dough makes the easiest cookies for christmas because it’s soft, simple, and totally reliable, which is exactly what you want when you’re trying to bake a full spread of frosted christmas cookies without breaking into a festive sweat.
What I love most about this basic christmas cookie dough is how it transforms the simplest ingredients into picture perfect christmas shaped cookies. From a classic santa cookie to a delicate snowflake cookie, a nostalgic gingerbread man cookie, a cute candy cane cookie, an adorable snowman cookie, and the iconic christmas tree cookie, each shape turns out clean and crisp every single time. And because christmas sugar cookies are one of the most competitive holiday recipes online, this post is loaded with icing tips, decorating ideas, and shape-by-shape guidance to help your homemade cookies look like the glossy bakery style iced christmas cookies we all obsess over during the holiday season.
Become a subscriber for free!
Subscribe to Drenched In Flavor’s email subscriber list to make sure you never miss a super tasty recipe. Fill out your email below to receive free recipes to your inbox every week!
Why this Christmas sugar cookies recipe works
- Perfect texture for decorating: These christmas sugar cookies stay soft in the middle but firm enough on the edges, making them ideal for all kinds of christmas shaped cookies, from a delicate snowflake cookie to a chunky gingerbread man cookie. This balance also makes icing easier, giving you flawless frosted christmas cookies every time.
- Easy to roll and cut: The dough rolls smoothly without sticking, which means even the most intricate snowflake cookie or candy cane cookie keeps its shape. That’s why this is one of the easiest cookies for christmas to make, especially if you’re planning a whole tray of iced christmas cookies.
- Holds vibrant icing: The soft yet sturdy texture lets your colored icing sit on top without melting into the cookie, so every santa cookie and christmas tree cookie comes out looking sharp and professional. These are the kind of holiday cookies for christmas that wow friends and family.
- Reliable results every time: Whether you’re baking for the first time or making dozens for holiday recipes, this basic christmas cookie dough produces consistent results. No spreading, no overly flat cookies, just picture-perfect iced christmas cookies ready for decorating.
- Versatile for shapes and themes: From classic christmas tree cookies to snowman cookies, candy cane cookies, or even themed gingerbread man cookies, this dough works for all types of christmas shaped cookies, making it a go-to recipe in your holiday recipes arsenal.
- Perfect for festive gift boxes: These cookies maintain their soft texture and decorated appearance even after a day or two, making them ideal for gifting or sharing at holiday parties, and they’re some of the best frosted christmas cookies to include in cookie tins.
How to make christmas sugar cookies:
Step 1: Cream butter and sugar
Start by creaming your butter and sugar until they turn pale, fluffy, and visibly lighter in texture. This step is what gives your christmas sugar cookies that soft but sturdy feel you want from holiday cookies for christmas. If the butter and sugar aren’t creamed enough, your cookies won’t bake evenly and they won’t have that clean golden edge. Take your time here, scrape the bowl, and make sure it’s fully fluffy before you move on.
Step 2: Beat the eggs
Beat in the eggs one at a time along with the vanilla paste. The mixture will thicken and become smooth and creamy, almost like a thick batter. This stage adds richness, keeps the dough from becoming dry, and helps the cookies stay tender even if you roll the dough slightly thinner for very detailed christmas shaped cookies like a delicate snowflake cookie.
Step 4: Add in dry ingredients
Add the flour and baking soda, mixing until the dough begins to form. It might seem a touch soft at first, which is why adding that extra half cup flour is important. You want a dough that’s soft and pliable but not sticky. Once it forms a ball, give it a short knead with your hands to help everything come together. This texture is what makes these some of the easiest cookies for Christmas because the dough behaves.
Step 5: Roll the Christmas cookie dough
Lightly flour your workspace and roll the dough to a consistent thickness. This is where the fun begins because you get to cut out all your christmas shaped cookies. I used a santa cookie cutter, a snowflake cookie cutter, a snowman cookie cutter, a candy cane cookie cutter, a gingerbread man cookie cutter, and a christmas tree cookie cutter. Each one releases cleanly thanks to the dough’s stability. Place them on a lined baking sheet with a little space between each.
Step 6: Bake the christmas cookies
Bake at 350F (180C) for around 13 minutes or until the cookies feel set in the middle but not soft, with a slight golden glow. They should still look fairly pale because that’s what keeps christmas sugar cookies soft and tender. Let them cool completely before icing. If they are even slightly warm, your icing will slide right off or melt into sugary puddles.
Step 7: Ice Sugar Cookies
Make your icing by mixing confectioners sugar with a few drops of water until you reach a thick, smooth, glossy consistency. Divide it into bowls and tint each one with food coloring according to the shape you’re decorating. This simple icing is what gives you that classic frosted christmas cookies look. Dont forget to check the guide below for details on how to ice each individual cookie shape.
Recipe FAQ
Q: Can I chill the dough first?
A: Yes! Chilling helps the shapes stay crisp, especially detailed ones like a snowflake cookie or Christmas tree cookie. Totally recommended if your kitchen is quite warm.
Q: How long do these Christmas sugar cookies stay soft?
A: Around 4 to 5 days in an airtight container. The cookies stay soft and perfect for icing the entire time.
Q: Can I freeze them?
A: Freeze the dough or freeze the baked cookies before decorating. Both options work great for holiday recipes and Christmas recipes prep.
Q: Why did my cookies spread?
A: Too little flour or warm dough. If you struggled to use the cookie cutters, you probably needed more flour, if not, your sugar cookie dough was too warm, pop in the fridge and chill before baking for perfect christmas shaped cookies.
Q: Can I make these thicker?
A: Yes, thicker cookies stay softer and make gorgeous frosted christmas cookies that have an almost cakey texture!
Q: What are Santas favourite cookies?
A: These Christmas sugar cookies, particularly the santa shaped ones.
Q: Are parents allowed to eat these cookies?
A: Parents and other adults may test one sugar cookie each for quality control purposes. All under the age of 18 may need to test two on Christmas eve. All cookies not eaten by Santa must be finished by the 27th of December. This guidance comes directly from The North Pole.
Q: Are reindeers allowed to eat these christmas cookies?
A: Reindeers love a little nibble but the dairy makes them quite gassy so carrots are preferred.
Q: Will Santa put me on his “nice” list if I make these cookies?
A: Yes, all children that have made these sugar cookies before 6pm on 24th December will automatically be redeemed and their names placed on the nice list.
Q: Can I double or triple the recipe?
A: Absolutely. Perfect if you’re making big batches of holiday cookies for christmas or filling cookie boxes.
How to decorate Santas Sugar Cookies:
- Stir together 2 tbsp confectioners sugar with a few drops of water to make a thick icing, then divide and tint bowls for red, white, pale pink, and darker pink. This keeps the icing perfect for easy Christmas sugar cookies and helps the colors stay bold.
- Use a toothpick or small brush to paint on the white beard, hat trim, and pom-pom using the natural outline of your Christmas cookie cutter as a guide. These little touches turn a basic Christmas cookie into the cutest Santa cookie.
- Add the red icing to the hat by outlining and then filling the top section so it stays neat and bright. Thick icing keeps these frosted Christmas cookies looking clean and smooth.
- Fill the face area with pale pink icing, let it sit for a few minutes, then dot on the darker nose and tiny black eyes. This quick set time makes homemade Christmas cookies look crisp and defined for Christmas Eve.
Extra tip: For sharp separated colors on your decorated Christmas cookies, let each section dry 15 minutes; for softer blended edges, wait just 1–2 minutes before switching colors.
How to decorate candy cane sugar cookies:
- Whisk up two small bowls of icing using the same simple sugar cookie recipe technique as Santa: thick white icing for the base and a bright red icing for the stripes. Thick icing makes these easy Christmas sugar cookies way less messy and helps those candy-cane lines stay super defined.
- Use a toothpick or mini brush to cover the entire cookie in white icing, letting it self-level into a smooth finish. This creates that glossy candy-cane look you see in classic decorated Christmas cookies.
- Once the white has set slightly, use the red icing to paint alternating diagonal stripes. Outline each stripe first with your toothpick, then fill it in so the red stays bold and clean. That simple move makes these homemade Christmas cookies look like you spent way longer on them than you did.
How to decorate snowflake sugar cookies:
- Whip up a bowl of bright white icing and a tiny bowl of pale blue icing for the snowflake details. This is one of the easiest Christmas sugar cookies because the design looks fancy even though it’s super simple.
- Flood the entire cookie with white icing and let it level out into a smooth, snowy base. Homemade Christmas cookie icing works best when thick because it won’t run off the edges.
- Using the pale blue icing, draw delicate veining lines along the main arms of the snowflake, letting them branch out naturally. These decorated Christmas cookies are perfect if you love winter comfort recipes that look like bakery treats.
Extra tip: Add the blue icing detail whilst the white is still wet, using a tooth pick to drag the blue through for a super smooth finish.
How to decorate Snowman sugar cookies:
- Mix some more white icing for the body, a tiny bowl of black icing for the hat and buttons, orange for the nose, and red for the scarf. This is the exact kind of decorating that makes a simple sugar cookie recipe feel like a full winter comfort recipe.
- Coat the whole snowman in thick white icing, letting it settle into a perfect smooth snow-look. Let it dry for a few minutes before adding details so each color stays sharp.
- Add the black hat first, outlining it with a toothpick before filling it in. Then dot on black buttons and tiny black eyes. These little touches are what make decorated Christmas cookies so magical.
- Use orange icing to tap on the cute carrot nose, then finish with a bright red scarf wrapped across his little neck. These homemade Christmas cookies always become the kid favorite.
How to decorate a Christmas tree cookie:
- Stir up a small bowl of green icing, a small bowl of brown icing for the trunk, and extra tiny bowls of red and blue for ornaments. That classic color combo seriously screams easy Christmas sugar cookies.
- Fill the entire tree with green icing, nudging it into each branch shape. Let it dry slightly so the decorations sit neatly on top instead of sinking in.
- Pipe or paint on the white zig-zag garland from top to bottom, then dot on the red and blue ornament candies. Finish with a swipe of brown icing at the bottom for the tree trunk. These homemade Christmas cookies always look adorable on a holiday platter.
How to decorate a gingerbread man cookie:
- Mix up a warm golden-brown icing for the body plus tiny bowls of white, black, and red icing for the classic details. Every time you decorate a cookie like this, the nostalgia hits in the best way, which is why gingerbread people are peak comfort recipes.
- Coat the cookie evenly in the brown icing and let it settle into a smooth finish. This gives you that glossy bakery-style look you see in the best decorated Christmas cookies.
- Add the smile and eyes with black icing, then use the white icing to pipe little arm and leg lines. Dot on three red buttons down the chest. It’s super simple yet ridiculously cute, which is exactly what an easy Christmas sugar cookie should be.
Latest Recipes:
- Ground Beef Tacos | Soft Shell Tacos
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich With Bacon
- White Chocolate And Raspberry Cookies
- The Best Pizza Dough – Overnight Pizza Recipe
- Chicken Bacon Pasta Salad
Become a subscriber for free!
Subscribe to Drenched In Flavor’s email subscriber list to make sure you never miss a super tasty recipe. Fill out your email below to receive free recipes to your inbox every week!
Iced Christmas Sugar Cookies Recipe
Equipment
- 4" christmas themed cookie cutters If buying online, check measurements, many amazon options are around 2" tall for mini cookies.
- cocktail stick or small paintbrush
Ingredients
- 1/2 cup sugar
- 1/2 cup softened butter
- 2 large eggs
- 1 tsp vanilla paste
- 2 2/3 cups all-purpose flour
- 1/2 tsp baking soda
- For icing: confectioners sugar + a few drops of water + gel food coloring for all your Christmas shaped cookies, Santa cookies, snowflake cookies, gingerbread man cookies, candy cane cookies, and Christmas tree cookies
Instructions
- Cream the butter and sugar with a spoon or mixer until the mixture looks pale and fluffy.
- Beat in the eggs and vanilla until smooth and creamy with no streaks.
- Add the flour and baking soda and mix until a soft dough forms; if it’s sticky, sprinkle in a little extra flour.
- Dust your counter with flour, roll the dough to about 1/4 inch thick, and cut out Christmas shapes with cookie cutters.
- Place on a lined baking sheet and bake at 350F (180C) for about 13 minutes, until the edges feel set and the centers are no longer soft.
- Cool completely on a rack, then mix thick icing (confectioners sugar + drops of water) and decorate your frosted Christmas cookies in festive colors. Check the details above for help with icing.
